Scene from an especially surreal Italian restaurant: Spaghetti & Meatballs goes home on Billy Joel Night

That's a spicy Meatball! But this Billy Joel impasta still had to say goodbye to Hollywood after competing against streetlife serenaders Clock, Lizard, and something called Poodle Moth.

Wednesday was Billy Joel Night on The Masked Singer, but I’m pretty sure when Billy Joel wrote “Scenes From an Italian Restaurant” he never imagined a bipedal, Pringles-mustachioed, anthropomorphic plate of meat lovers’ pasta singing one of his songs.

However, that’s exactly what happened when Spaghetti & Meatballs, sounding so much like Billy Joel that one snarky YouTube commenter even guessed it was the piano man himself, performed this week on Season 11’s Group C premiere. As it turns out, this spicy singer was not Billy Joel, but he was a pretty convincing imposter — or impasta, if you will.